This Article argues that press outlets should be completely immune from defamation suits initiated by a US President. The Article presents the current defamation standard for public officials and explores the history of tense President-press relations. It then argues that defamation lawsuits are a dangerous tool in the hands of a sitting President and that the potential for abuse of these lawsuits makes them inconsistent with the First Amendment. In support of this claim, the author offers several doctrinal and policy rationales for eliminating the New York Times Co v Sullivan standard with respect to a sitting President in favor of a zero-liability rule. In a political climate dominated by charges of ‘Fake News’ and with the election of a notoriously litigious President, now is an opportune time to explore the implications of allowing a sitting President to bring a cause of action for defamation.
Zaharoff, Zachary, Defaming the Prince (May 23, 2017).